Scott Gregorio is an MLB player and All-Star homerun hitter featured on the show. He was revealed to be a centerpiece in the murders of Lawrence and Erin Hammond. He was on the verge of breaking a home run record that was held for 3 years. He was almost attacked by Walker Browning with a baseball bat but fended off the attacker. When it was discovered that he had an affair with Erin Hammond, Walker killed both her and Lawrence just to get Scott off his game. Monk then reached out to Scott in helping Benjy improve on his game. Even after Walker was arrested for Double Homicide, Scott failed to break the record.