Mr. Monk Fights City Hall

Synopsis[]

Plot[]

Background[]

"What are you doing?"[]

Quotes[]

Here's What Happened[]

Mr. Monk Fights City Hall is the seventh season finale of Monk.

Desperate to save the parking lot where Trudy was killed from demolition, Monk enlists the help of a sympathetic councilwoman. But when she goes missing, Monk may be forced to deal with her hapless assistant.

A demolition crew is preparing to level a parking garage in downtown San Francisco, to make way for a children's playground. But the workmen call a halt and tell the foreman that "some nut" has chained himself to a concrete post inside. The nut is Adrian Monk, who refuses to budge. He explains that his wife, Trudy, was murdered there, and there may still be evidence somewhere leading to her killer. Eileen Hill, a city councilwoman who led the effort to demolish the garage, approaches Monk and, sympathizing with his passion, agrees to halt the demolition and put the matter to a new vote before the council. Relieved, Monk unchains himself.

Days later, Monk is called to a murder scene. Two German tourists, husband and wife, were killed on an isolated pier. Monk tries to focus on the case, but the new City Council vote on the garage demolition is happening later that day, and Monk can’t wait to get there. Despite his lack of concentration, Monk is able to deduce that the tourists were not killed for money, but for something they witnessed.

With Monk’s work at the crime scene done, he hurries off to City Hall, where he meets a newspaper reporter, Paul Crawford, who’s there covering Monk’s fight to save the garage. Monk also runs into his nemesis, Harold Krenshaw, who happens to be a member of the City Council. Fortunately for Monk, he doesn’t need Harold’s vote. Councilwoman Hill has assured Monk that she will vote to save the garage, which is enough to give Monk the majority he needs.

Then Monk gets some bad news. Councilwoman Hill is missing, and the vote on the garage measure is postponed. Monk is desperate to find her, as she is the key to saving the garage. He goes to the councilwoman’s office and talks to her secretary, Maria Schecter, whose extreme incompetence frustrates Monk. Monk learns that the councilwoman’s last meeting before she went missing was with the reporter, Paul Crawford.

Monk talks to Crawford, who admits to meeting with Eileen Hill before she disappeared. According to Crawford, there was nothing unusual about the councilwoman’s behavior, but he recommends talking to a hot dog vendor named George Gionopolis, "the Hot Dog Czar," who’s been holding a grudge against her. Monk follows up on Crawford’s suggestion, but the vendor appears to have nothing to do with the councilwoman’s disappearance. However, it is clear that he does have a grudge of sorts. Thanks to Eileen Hill, the hot dog vendors of the city have to change the water every other day, and they must put the word "meat" in quotes. Ultimately, George is cleared when he passes a polygraph, and surveillance cameras show Hill never went near his warehouse. Monk becomes extremely desperate to find Councilwoman Hill and save the Parking Garage by putting up flyers with a $1,000 reward.

During Monk's regular session with Dr. Bell, he can talk about nothing but the garage issue. Dr. Bell reminds Monk that he's regularly visited the garage every year since Trudy was killed, and asks him whether he truly believes that there is still undiscovered evidence there that may lead to Trudy's killer. Monk admits that he doesn't; to him, the place where Trudy died is a sacred place, that he can't bear to see destroyed. He tells Dr. Bell that the last thing Trudy saw were the letters B-5 in red. When Monk muses over the possible whereabouts of Councilwoman Hill, Dr. Bell mentions that he is familiar with the strain of the job, and inadvertently gives Monk a new plan to save the garage.

Monk goes to the councilwoman’s assistant, Maria, and convinces her to vote as Hill's proxy, as Maria is allowed to do under the city’s bylaws. He does so in a variety of ways, including waving the flowers about and sitting on her desk, hesitating to pay $3 for her hot dog, meeting the vendor again and saying "It's a pleasure to see you again" while making quotations marks with his fingers, Monk promising not to tell the receptionist's child (20 years later) that she ate "hot dogs" during her pregnancy, Monk asserting that the kids don't need a playground -- they could use their imagination and play in the garage. Maria is intrigued, figuring she owes it to Hill. After all, Maria found the job at her Lamaze class and all she had to do was take a drug test.

While she's eating, she tells Monk she'd be more confident in that decision if she could read Hill's journal, and asks if they checked for it at her apartment, to which he tells her they did. Then she asks if they checked her other apartment. Maria apparently knew of this apartment the whole time, but since nobody asked her about it, she never brought it up before now.

Monk and Natalie go to the apartment, which was obviously some sort of love nest. While snooping around, Natalie finds a home pregnancy test that has come up positive. If the councilwoman was having an affair and got pregnant, perhaps her lover is responsible for her disappearance. But with whom was she having the affair?

Unfortunately, any answers won’t be coming from the councilwoman, as her dead body has washed up in waters not far from where the German tourists were found, indicating that's where the killer dumped her. The councilwoman was strangled with an expensive necktie that typically isn't found in the United States before she was dropped in the water, and in a strange development, medical tests show that the councilwoman was not pregnant. There’s a lot to sort out, but Monk is more concerned about the latest City Council vote on the garage issue, which is about to take place.

Monk rushes to City Hall and shows Maria a photocopy of a journal that was found with Councilwoman Hill’s body in which the councilwoman writes of her intentions to vote in favor of keeping the garage. Based on this, Maria casts the deciding vote in favor of keeping the garage.

After the vote, Monk is in a celebratory mood, and he invites everyone out for drinks. Because she’s pregnant and can’t drink alcohol, Maria declines. This reminds Monk of an earlier conversation he had with the reporter, Paul Crawford. When Crawford was asked if the councilwoman had been drinking when he met with her, he said, “She wouldn’t be drinking now.” It was a strange way to answer the question, and now, after Maria’s response to Monk’s invitation, Monk knows why Crawford responded that way. Crawford thought that the councilwoman was pregnant.

Crawford, who is married to the daughter of a billionaire, was having an illicit affair with the councilwoman. Hill was trying to persuade Crawford to leave his wife, and decided to give him an extra "push" by deceiving him into thinking she was pregnant with his child. To carry out this deception, Hill hired Maria, took her urine under the pretense of a drug test, and used the urine to trigger a positive result on a pregnancy test. Monk insists that this is the only explanation that makes sense, given Maria's spectacular incompetence as an assistant.

Hill showed the test to Crawford, but the plan backfired; Crawford could likely hide an affair from his wife, but he certainly couldn't explain how Hill got pregnant without revealing the affair. So in order to keep his marriage (and more importantly, the money his wife could provide), he had to kill Eileen. The German tourists must have witnessed Crawford dumping the councilwoman’s body off the pier, and they had to die, too.

The final piece of evidence is the necktie Crawford is wearing, which is the same, custom-made style as was used to strangle Councilwoman Hill. Crawford is arrested, but Maria, insulted by Monk's summation, decides to change her position, and Harold gleefully calls for another vote. To add insult to injury, a slip from Natalie has allowed Harold to learn the name of Monk's new therapist, about whom Monk has been bragging, and Harold announces that he looks forward to seeing Monk "in the waiting room."

In a repeat of the opening scene, the construction crew is about to demolish the garage, but are forced to wait a few moments while Monk says an emotional farewell to the garage. He looks tearfully at the letters B-5. As Natalie leads him out, they pass a sign declaring the future site of "The Trudy Monk Memorial Playground," indicating that Monk's fight to preserve the memory of his beloved wife wasn't completely in vain.

The murder of Eileen Hill is inspired by the murder of Dr. Deepti Gupta by Kevin Paul Anderson.
Similar to Season Six's "Mr. Monk and the Man Who Shot Santa Claus," the promotional spots for this episode suggested that Monk would discover more clues about Trudy's murder, but the episode disappointed that promise.
Monk and Eileen Hill say several times that he is opposed to tearing down the garage because Trudy died there but Trudy actually died at the hospital, living just long enough to say "Bread and Butter" to Monk. However; this is because Monk is referring to the fact that the car bombing that killed Trudy took place there.
When Monk and Natalie run into Harold coming out of the elevator, Harold tells Monk that he will change his vote in Monk's favor in exchange for the name of his therapist. However, during "Mr. Monk Gets Hypnotized" Monk tells Harold Dr. Bell's name when they meet at the scene of Sally Larkin's abandoned car. Although, at the time Harold was seeing Dr. Climan, a hypnotist and may not remember the exchange.

In every episode of Monk and the Monk Movie, at least once, some variation of the question, "What are you doing?" is asked.

Time	Quote	From	To	RE
0:00	What the hell do you think you're doing?	Forman	Monk	Monk chained to a pillar in the parking garage.

Season 7 (Monk)

Season 6

Season 8

Adrian Monk: Hell no, we won't go!

Dr. Bell: You're standing up. Why don't you just sit down?

Adrian Monk: I think you're a genius.

Dr. Bell: Okay, you can stand